How much of it was your fault
Ohio reduces recovery by your share of the blame, so an insurer has a direct financial incentive to argue your share was larger than it was.
Cincinnati · Middletown · Hamilton · Dayton
Call us anytime, 24/7: 513-909-9999
Hurt by a driver who was not paying attention? We deal with the insurance company so you can get on with getting better.
No fee unless we win
Free consultation, no fee unless we win.
No fee unless we win
In the first week after a crash you are dealing with a body that hurts, a car you may not be able to drive, work you cannot get to, and a phone that will not stop ringing. Somewhere in that week an adjuster for the other driver’s insurer will call, sound perfectly friendly, and ask you to walk through what happened.
That call is not a formality. It is the other side starting its file. Anything you say about how you feel that day, before anyone knows what is actually wrong, can be quoted back months later to argue that your injuries were minor and that the claim should settle for very little.
You are not required to give that statement on the spot, and you are not required to decide anything on the phone.
You were hurt in a car accident in Ohio that someone else caused, or mostly caused. Perhaps you have already spoken to an insurer and wish you had not. Either way, having someone look at it costs you nothing.
Adrenaline masks a great deal. Soft-tissue injuries, disc injuries and concussions often declare themselves two or three days later, once the shock has worn off. A gap between the crash and your first medical visit is the single most common thing an insurer uses to argue you were not really hurt, so being seen early protects your health and your claim at the same time.
A police report is not the last word on fault, but it is the first document everyone reads, and a crash with no report at all is much harder to prove. If an officer attended, note the agency and the report number.
Both vehicles from several angles, their final positions, skid marks, debris, the intersection and its traffic controls, the weather and the light, and any visible injury. A scene is cleared within the hour; photographs taken then cannot be argued with later.
An independent witness who saw the light change is worth more than any argument made afterwards, and they become impossible to find once everyone has driven away.
Your own policy generally requires you to report a crash promptly, and your own coverage may be the one that pays if the other driver has none. That is a different thing from giving the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement, which you are generally under no obligation to do.
Bills, discharge instructions, referrals, prescriptions, mileage to appointments, days missed from work, and a short note of what you could not do that week. Claims are proved with documentation, and the small records are the ones nobody keeps.
An early check almost always arrives before anyone knows the full medical picture. Once it is accepted and the release is signed, the claim is finished, including for treatment you have not had yet.
Every crash is different, but the injuries that follow passenger-vehicle collisions fall into familiar groups:
Two things matter more than the label on the injury: whether it is documented, and whether the record connects it to the crash. Both are easier to establish early than to reconstruct later.
Most people expect liability to be the argument. Often it is not, the other driver plainly ran the light. The argument is about everything that comes after that.
Ohio reduces recovery by your share of the blame, so an insurer has a direct financial incentive to argue your share was larger than it was.
A prior back complaint in your records will be offered as the real explanation for your pain, even where the crash clearly made it worse.
Two weeks without an appointment, because you could not get childcare or could not afford the co-pay, gets characterized as recovery.
The at-fault driver’s coverage can be far smaller than the harm done, which turns the question into what other coverage exists, including your own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.
Health insurers and medical providers may have a right to be repaid out of a settlement. A number that looks fine before those are addressed can shrink badly afterwards.
A settlement is final. Future treatment has to be valued before you sign, not after.
We gather the records rather than asking you to chase them, establish what happened from the physical evidence rather than from the adjuster’s summary, identify every policy that could respond, and put a documented value on the claim before we discuss numbers with anyone. When the offer does not reflect that value, we are prepared to say so and to keep going.
You get one claim for this crash, let’s maximize its value and get you what you deserve.
There is no charge for the consultation and no retainer to get started. Car accident cases are handled on a contingency fee: our fee is a share of what we recover for you and is paid out of that recovery. If we recover nothing, you owe us no fee. You will never receive an hourly bill from this firm.
That matters for a practical reason. The people who most need a lawyer after a crash are usually the ones with the least spare money at that exact moment. The fee structure exists so that being short of money is not the reason a good claim goes unmade.
General information, not legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts. The only way to know where yours stands is to have someone look at it.
Anyone who gives you a number before seeing your medical records is guessing. What a claim is worth depends on the injuries and how well they are documented, the treatment you have had and are still likely to need, earnings you have lost, how the injury has changed daily life, the share of fault in dispute, and, often decisively, how much insurance coverage exists to pay it. What we can tell you early is which of those factors are in play in your case and what would strengthen them.
You are generally under no obligation to, and it is worth speaking to a lawyer before you do. Adjusters are trained and experienced; you are doing this for the first time, probably on medication, and probably before anyone has told you what is actually wrong with you. Questions that sound sympathetic: how are you feeling today, had your back ever bothered you before, are recorded and quoted back later. Declining politely and referring them to your lawyer is normal and costs you nothing.
Ohio sets a deadline for bringing a personal injury claim, and once it passes the claim is generally lost no matter how strong it was. Shorter and different deadlines can apply in particular situations, notably where a government entity or public vehicle is involved. Because the consequence of getting this wrong is total, it is worth confirming your specific deadline early rather than assuming. Ohio generally allows two years from the date a personal injury claim arises to bring it (Ohio Revised Code § 2305.10), and two years from the date of death in a wrongful death claim (§ 2125.02). Shorter notice periods can apply where a government entity or public vehicle is involved, so confirm your own deadline early rather than assuming.
You may well still recover. Ohio uses a comparative negligence system, which reduces what you receive by your share of the fault rather than barring the claim outright, up to a threshold beyond which recovery is not available. Insurers understand this perfectly and routinely argue for a larger share of blame than the evidence supports, because every percentage point is money off the claim.
This is more common than people expect, and it is not necessarily the end of the claim. Your own policy may include uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, which is designed for exactly this situation and pays regardless of the other driver having nothing. Many people carry it without realizing. It is one of the first things we check, because it can be the difference between a claim with no source of payment and one that resolves properly.
Almost certainly not. It is not ideal, and it may mean some early answers need to be put in context later, but a recorded statement is one piece of evidence among many, not a binding agreement about what your case is worth. What matters far more is what you do from here: get properly assessed, keep treating, stop discussing the claim with the insurer, and get someone to look at the file.
Vehicle damage is usually handled as a separate property-damage claim and often resolves much sooner than the injury claim. Be careful of one thing: a release you sign for the vehicle should relate to the vehicle only. Read what you are signing, or have someone read it, so that settling the car does not accidentally settle the injury.
It depends mostly on your medical treatment, not on the lawyers. A claim generally should not be valued until your treatment has finished or your doctors can say what your long-term condition will be, settling before that means guessing at your own future. Straightforward claims can resolve in months; cases involving serious injury, disputed fault or litigation take longer. We would rather tell you honestly that it will take time than rush you into a number that will not cover what is coming.
Most car accident claims settle without a trial. But settlement value is heavily influenced by whether the other side believes you are willing and able to go to court, so a case should be prepared as though it might be tried. If it does become necessary, we will tell you well in advance what it involves and what to expect.
Passengers are rarely at fault for anything, which usually makes liability straightforward. It can be uncomfortable when the at-fault driver is a friend or family member, but the claim is made against their insurance policy, which exists for precisely this purpose, rather than against them personally.
A truck or motorcycle crash follows different rules and different evidence. If yours involved either, start there instead.
A crash that happens while you are working can be a workers’ compensation claim and an injury claim at the same time. An injury that stops you working can become a disability claim.
Casper, Casper & Casper have always done an excellent job for us. We have used them once before and are now using them again and both times they have been super professional and always on top of our cases. Communication is easy and they are friendly and actually seem to care about the case.
I was very pleased with how the firm handled my case. They took care of everything and kept me inform through the entire process. There was not any surprises and the result was what I was expecting. I appreciate the care and time the firm took on my case.
From the get go I was constantly updated with what was going on with my case. Given realistic time frames about how the case should go. If I ever needed to speak with someone about my case I always got a call back quickly. They won my case for me way ahead of time. I feel truly blessed by having the Casper team handling my case. The whole process went through amazingly fast with no pressure on me.
By far, the best Law firm and representative I have ever had. The paralegals the lawyers the whole team is very professional very patient very understanding very kind. Communication is perfect, and I am just so grateful to have came across the Casper team. I 100% recommend them for your legal needs.
They did a great job for me, they explained the process to me until I fully understood it. All I had to do was answer a few questions and they took care of the rest. They were able to win my case for me and I am truly thankful they did.
From the first day I spoke with Mr Steve Casper he was certain we would win my case. He gave me all the confidence that I needed. It's been a long journey but well worth it. We made it and with a win!! Mr Steve Casper is amazing. Ben his assistant is very nice and very knowledgeable too.
One call starts your free case review. Available 24/7.
Free consultation, no fee unless we win.
No fee unless we win